| 1801–1815 | Col. Campbell, Younger of Shawfield |
| 1815–1838 | Reginald MacDonald of Staffa (afterwards Sir Reginald MacDonald Stewart Seaton, Bart.) |
| 1838–1840 | Walter Frederick Campbell of Shawfield and Islay |
| 1840–1875 – Dormant | |
| Provincial Grand Lodge resuscitated – December 1875 | |
| 1875–1911 | Sir Charles Dalrymple, Bart. |
| 1911–1916 | Major Henry Gerard Fenton-Newall (P.M. 292) |
| 1916–1938 | Frederick Walter Fell Clark, J.P., of Glen Caladh (P.M. 1120, Past Depute Grand Master) |
| 1938–1943 | John MacLachlan, J.P. (P.M. 292) |
| 1943–1948 | John Smith, J.P. (P.M. 141) |
| 1948–1953 | William MacDonald (P.M. 180) |
| 1953–1955 | Dr T. Simpson Crawford (P.M. 1435) |
| 1955–1960 | John Burgess, J.P., C.A. (P.M. 141) |
| 1960–1968 | Alister MacLeod (P.M. 180) |
| 1968–1973 | Walter B. MacNeil (P.M. 1120) |
| 1973–1978 | Francis E. Hutchinson (P.M. 335) |
| 1978–1983 | Hugh Thompson, T.D., A.I.C.S. (P.M. 141) |
| 1983–1988 | Angus Ferguson (P.M. 985) |
| 1988–1998 | Geoffrey H. Spearman (P.M. 1120) |
| 1998–2003 | Francis A. Mapes (P.M. 459) |
| 2003–2008 | Eric E. Coles (P.M. 754) |
| 2008–2013 | Douglas Craig (P.M. 180) |
| 2013–2018 | Kenneth Ronald Johnson (P.M. 141) |
| 2018–2023 | Douglas Trevor Philand (P.M. 754) |
